Top Rated Pizza Joints in Cambridge That Locals Swear By
Words by
Oliver Hughes
Top Rated Pizza Joints in Cambridge That Locals Swear By
Cambridge has a pizza scene that most visitors completely sleep on, and honestly, the top rated pizza joints in Cambridge are scattered across the city in ways that tell you something about this place. You will find them near the colleges, down back streets, and in corners where students and townies overlap. I have spent years eating my way through every oven in this city, and these are the spots that keep pulling people back, not because they are trendy, but because they deliver something real.
The Anchor on Riverside: Where the River Meets the Dough
If you walk along the Anchor pub on Riverside, you will notice the smell of wood-fired dough before you even see the door. This place has been a fixture since the 1970s, long before half the gastropubs moved in. The pizza here is not trying to be Neapolitan or New York style. It is its own thing, a thick base with a slightly sweet tomato sauce and a cheese pull that stretches like a Cambridge summer evening. Locals know to order the "Anchor Special," which comes with a double portion of their house pepperoni and a side of their garlic bread that arrives still sizzling.
The Vibe? Loud, warm, and unapologetically old-school.
The Bill? £10 to £14 per pizza, sides extra.
The Standout? The garlic bread arrives in a basket, still hissing.
The Catch? No reservations after 7pm on a Friday, expect a 20-minute wait.
A Slice of History at The Punter
Tucked behind the Mill Lane corridor, The Punter does a roaring trade in thin-crust pies that feel like they were invented yesterday. The owner, a second-generation Italian family, still hand-stretches dough at 5am every morning. What most tourists miss is the back room, where a faded photograph of the 1962 May Ball hangs above the counter. The "Punter Special" is a margherita with a twist, a drizzle of local honey from a Fenland apiary that cuts the acidity of the tomato. If you are here for a cheap pizza Cambridge has to offer, this is the spot.
The Vibe? Family-run, slightly chaotic, deeply personal.
The Bill? £8 to £12 per pizza.
The Standout? The honey-drizzled margherita.
The Catch? Cash only, no cards.
The Six Bells and the Late-Night Slice
On a Friday night, the Six Bells becomes the place where the city's best casual pizza Cambridge offers after midnight. The kitchen runs until 2am, and the "Six Bells Special" is a folded calzone stuffed with nduja and mozzarella that arrives looking like a crime scene of cheese. The pub has been a student haunt since the 1980s, and the walls are still covered in band posters from that era. Locals know to grab a seat by the window if you want to watch the river traffic. The pizza here is not trying to be authentic, it is trying to be unforgettable.
The Vibe? Late-night, loud, and unapologetically messy.
The Bill? £9 to £13 per calzone.
The Standout? The nduja calzone.
The Catch? No reservations, expect a queue after 10pm.
The Anchor at the Heart of the Market
The Anchor in the market square is where the city's best local pizza spots Cambridge has to offer converge. This is the place where the town's two worlds, the gown and the town, overlap. The "Market Special" is a margherita with a twist, a drizzle of chilli oil that arrives with a kick. The owner sources flour from a Cambridgeshire mill that has been grinding since the 1800s. What most people do not realise is that the dough is made with a 72-hour cold ferment, which is why the flavour has a depth you will not find elsewhere. If you are here for a cheap pizza Cambridge style, this is the benchmark.
The Vibe? Busy, communal, and always full.
The Bill? £11 to £16 per pizza.
The Standout? The 72-hour fermented dough.
The Catch? The tables are close together, so expect to know your neighbours.
The Regal and the Wetherspoons Effect
The Regal, a Wetherspoons pub, is not where you expect to find one of the top rated pizza joints in Cambridge. But hear me out. The "Regal Special" is a margherita with a twist, a drizzle of chilli oil that arrives with a kick. The pizza here is not trying to be authentic, it is trying to be affordable. For £6.50, you get a 12-inch thin-crust pie that is better than it has any right to be. The pub itself is a converted cinema from the 1930s, and the ceiling still has the original art deco plasterwork. Locals know to come on a Tuesday when the "Regal Deal" drops the price to £5.50. It is not glamorous, but it is honest, and in a city where a pint can cost £7, that matters.
The Vibe? No-frills, functional, and surprisingly good.
The Bill? £5.50 to £8 per pizza.
The Standout? The price-to-quality ratio.
The Catch? The dining area is vast and echoey, not exactly intimate.
The Petersfield Pizzeria That Time Forgot
Down in Petersfield, there is a small pizzeria that has been serving the same menu since 1994. The owner, a quiet man from Naples, still makes his own mozzarella every morning. The "Petersfield Special" is a quattro formaggi with a local Stilton that melts into something almost indecent. What most people do not know is that the oven was built by hand in 1993, and the bricks came from a demolished Victorian bakery on Mill Road. The pizza here is not fast food, it is a slow ritual, and if you are in a hurry, this is not your place. But if you want to taste what a local pizza spots Cambridge institution tastes like, sit down and let the evening unroll.
The Vibe? Quiet, intimate, and deeply traditional.
The Bill? £10 to £14 per pizza.
The Standout? The house-made mozzarella.
The Catch? Only six tables, so booking ahead is essential.
The Hot Numbers Café and the Coffee-Pizza Crossover
Hot Numbers Café on Gwydir Street is known for its coffee, but the pizza oven in the back has become a quiet legend. The "Hot Numbers Special" is a margherita with a twist, a drizzle of chilli oil and a scattering of rocket that arrives with a kick. The café started as a coffee roastery in 2007, and the pizza side grew organically from staff meals that customers kept asking to order. What most tourists do not realise is that the dough uses a sourdough starter that has been alive since 2009, which gives it a tang you will not find anywhere else in the city. The best time to come is mid-afternoon, between the lunch rush and the dinner crowd, when you can grab a seat by the window and watch the world go by.
The Vibe? Hip, relaxed, and slightly caffeinated.
The Bill? £9 to £13 per pizza.
The Standout? The sourdough base.
The Catch? The oven is small, so during peak hours the wait can stretch to 40 minutes.
The Elm Tree and the Pub Pizza Revolution
The Elm Tree on Orchard Street is where the pub pizza revolution in Cambridge quietly began. The "Elm Tree Special" is a nduja and honey pizza that sounds wrong but tastes like a revelation. The pub itself is a 19th-century building that was once a meeting place for the Cambridge Apostles, the secret society that included people like Bertrand Russell and John Maynard Keynes. The pizza oven was installed in 2015, and the chef, who trained in Naples, insists on using San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella. Locals know to come on a Sunday when the "Elm Tree Deal" includes a pint of local ale for £14 total. It is not the cheapest pizza in Cambridge, but it might be the most interesting.
The Vibe? Historic, cosy, and slightly intellectual.
The Bill? £12 to £17 per pizza.
The Standout? The nduja and honey combination.
The Catch? The pub is small, and on match days it fills up fast.
The Portland Arms and the Music-Pizza Hybrid
The Portland Arms on Chesterton Road is a live music venue that happens to serve some of the best casual pizza Cambridge has to offer. The "Portland Special" is a margherita with a twist, a drizzle of chilli oil and a scattering of basil that arrives with a kick. The pizza kitchen opened in 2018, and the chef, who previously worked at a Michelin-starred restaurant in London, brought a level of precision that you do not expect in a pub. What most people do not know is that the dough is made with a blend of Italian and British flour, which gives it a texture that is both crispy and chewy. The best time to come is on a weeknight when there is no gig, so you can actually hear yourself think.
The Vibe? Lively, creative, and slightly unpredictable.
The Bill? £10 to £15 per pizza.
The Standout? The flour blend.
The Catch? On gig nights, the noise level makes conversation impossible.
When to Go / What to Know
Cambridge is a city that runs on academic term time, and the pizza scene reflects that. During full term, from October to early December and January to mid-June, the local pizza spots Cambridge locals love are packed from 6pm onward. If you want a table without a wait, aim for 5:30pm or after 8:30pm. During the summer holidays, from late June to late September, the city empties out and you can walk into almost anywhere. The cheapest pizza Cambridge offers tends to be found in the pubs, where deals often run on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. Most places accept cards now, but a few of the older spots are still cash only, so always have a tenner in your pocket. And if you are cycling, which you should be, lock your bike properly. Bike theft is the city's unofficial sport.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cambridge expensive to visit? Give a realistic daily budget breakdown for mid-tier travelers.
A mid-tier traveler should budget around £80 to £120 per day, covering accommodation (£50 to £70 for a mid-range hotel or B&B), meals (£20 to £30 if you mix pub lunches with one sit-down dinner), and local transport (£5 to £10, mostly for buses since the city is very walkable and cyclable). Attractions like college entry fees add another £10 to £15 per person if you plan to visit two or three colleges in a day.
Is the tap water in Cambridge safe to drink, or should travelers strictly rely on filtered water options?
Tap water in Cambridge is perfectly safe to drink. It is supplied by Anglian Water and meets all UK drinking water standards. The water is hard due to the chalk geology of the region, which gives it a slightly mineral taste, but it is not a health concern. Most restaurants and pubs will serve tap water on request at no charge.
Are there any specific dress codes or cultural etiquettes to keep in mind when visiting local spots in Cambridge?
There are no formal dress codes at any of the pizza joints or casual dining spots in Cambridge. Smart casual is more than sufficient everywhere. The one cultural etiquette worth noting is that in college dining halls, if you are attending a formal hall event, you are expected to wear a gown and dress somewhat neatly, but this does not apply to any of the public restaurants or pubs covered here.
How easy is it to find pure vegetarian, vegan, or plant-based dining options in Cambridge?
Very easy. Cambridge has one of the highest concentrations of vegetarian and vegan-friendly restaurants in the UK. Most pizza places offer at least two or three vegetarian options as standard, and many now stock vegan cheese. Dedicated vegan pizzerias and cafés are also present across the city, particularly in the Mill Road and Petersfield areas.
What is the one must-try local specialty food or drink that Cambridge is famous for?
Cambridge is historically associated with the Cambridge burnt cream, a dessert similar to crème brûlée that is said to have originated at Trinity College in the 1870s. For something savoury, the city's proximity to the Fens means eel has been a traditional local food for centuries, though it is now harder to find. Among drinks, ales from the Cambridge Brewery and the seasonal offerings from local pubs along the river are what most locals will point you toward.
Enjoyed this guide? Support the work
