Top Rated Pizza Joints in San Andres That Locals Swear By
Words by
Andres Restrepo
I've spent the better part of three years eating my way through every corner of San Andres Island, and if there's one thing I can tell you with absolute certainty, it's that the top rated pizza joints in San Andres are not what most travel blogs lead you to believe. Forget the resort menus and the overpriced beachfront places pushing "gourmet" pies for 80,000 pesos. The real magic happens in the small, family-run spots tucked into the barrios of the island's interior, where the dough is hand-stretched at dawn and the sauce has been simmering since the morning. This guide is born from countless evenings wandering the streets of San Andres town, from the busy stretch along Avenida Colombia to the quieter residential lanes near El Centro, where locals line up for a slice that actually tastes like something. I've eaten at every place on this list, some of them dozens of times, and I'm giving you the honest truth, including the things that aren't perfect.
The Heart of Local Pizza Culture in San Andres
San Andres Island sits about 750 kilometers off the Colombian mainland, a tiny Caribbean speck with a population of roughly 75,000 people, and its food culture is a fascinating collision of Raizal tradition, mainland Colombian influence, and decades of tourism-driven experimentation. Pizza arrived here not through Italian immigrants, as it did in Buenos Aires or New York, but through the island's openness to mainland Colombian and international visitors starting in the 1950s and 60s. What emerged is something entirely its own, a pizza culture that borrows from Neapolitan tradition but adapts to island ingredients and island tastes. The local pizza spots San Andres residents talk about with real affection are places that have been around for years, some for over a decade, run by families who learned the craft from relatives on the mainland or who simply figured it out through trial and error. The dough here tends to be thinner than what you'd find in Bogota, the toppings lean heavily on local seafood and tropical produce, and the portions are generous because island culture values abundance. Understanding this context matters before you walk into any of the places I'm about to describe. You're not getting Italian pizza. You're getting San Andres pizza, and that's a different, wonderful thing.
1. Panadería y Pizzería El Rincón del Sabor (Barrio El Centro, Calle 2 near the market)
I walked into El Rincón del Sabor on a Tuesday evening around 7 PM, and the place was half full of families eating dinner together, kids running between tables, the owner's mother sitting near the counter folding napkins. This is the kind of spot that doesn't appear on TripAdvisor but shows up in every local conversation about cheap pizza San Andres has to offer. The menu is handwritten on a whiteboard behind the counter, and the pizza margherita costs around 18,000 pesos for a personal-sized pie, which is about as affordable as it gets on the island. What makes it worth going to is the crust, which has a slightly sweet, almost coconut-bread quality that comes from the dough recipe the owner brought from Providencia Island. They also do a shrimp pizza that uses locally caught shrimp, and it's the best seafood pizza I've had on the island, hands down. The best time to visit is weekday evenings between 6 and 8 PM, before the after-work crowd fills up the small dining room. Most tourists never find this place because it's a block off the main tourist strip and has no English signage.
Local Insider Tip: "Ask for the 'especial de la abuela' which isn't on the menu. It's a pizza with a thin layer of plantain mash spread under the cheese. The owner's grandmother's recipe. They'll make it if you ask nicely and it's not too busy."
The connection here is to the Raizal community's tradition of blending Caribbean ingredients with mainland formats. This isn't fusion for tourists. It's how people here actually eat.
2. Pizzería La Nueva (Avenida Colombia, between Calles 3 and 4)
La Nueva has been on Avenida Colombia for at least eight years now, and it occupies that sweet spot between tourist-facing and genuinely local. I went there last Thursday around 8:30 PM, and the place was packed with a mix of Colombian mainland visitors and island regulars. The best casual pizza San Andres offers in a sit-down setting is probably what you'll find here. They do a four-cheese pizza with a local twist, adding a mild coastal cheese that melts differently than standard mozzarella, giving it a stretchier, almost stringy texture. A large pizza runs about 45,000 to 55,000 pesos depending on toppings. The best time to go is Thursday through Saturday after 8 PM, when they fire up the wood-burning oven that they only use on weekends and the atmosphere shifts from casual lunch spot to something closer to a neighborhood gathering place. What most tourists don't know is that the back room, past the kitchen, has a second dining area with ceiling fans and no air conditioning, and the locals always ask to sit back there because the pizza comes out faster since it's closer to the oven.
Local Insider Tip: "If you're ordering the calzone, tell them 'bien cerrado' when you order. It means you want the edges sealed tight and extra crisped. The default is a softer fold, which is fine, but the crisped version is what the regulars prefer."
La Nueva represents the generation of pizza places that grew up alongside San Andres' tourism boom, adapting to both local tastes and visitor expectations without losing either.
3. Johnny's Pizza (Barrio Sarie Bay, near the commercial zone)
Johnny's is the place I recommend to people who want something quick, reliable, and close to the hotel zone without paying resort prices. Located in the Sarie Bay commercial area, it's a small operation, maybe six tables, run by a guy named Johnny who came to the island from Cartagena about twelve years ago. I ate there three times in the past month alone. The pepperoni pizza is solid, nothing revolutionary, but the real star is the Hawaiian pizza, which they make with actual fresh pineapple chunks rather than canned, and the sweetness hits different when the fruit is local. A personal pizza is around 20,000 pesos, and a large is about 40,000. Best time to visit is lunch, between noon and 2 PM, when Johnny himself is usually behind the counter and the pace is relaxed. Tourists tend to walk right past this place because the signage is small and partially blocked by a palm tree, but the locals in Sarie Bay know it well.
Local Insider Tip: "Johnny sometimes has a 'pizza del día' written on a small chalkboard by the door. It's usually whatever ingredients he picked up fresh that morning from the market near the pier. It's almost always worth ordering whatever it is."
Johnny's is a reminder that some of the best food on San Andres comes from people who arrived from somewhere else and decided to stay.
4. Pizzería y Restaurante El Italiano (Calle 1, near the church)
El Italiano sits on Calle 1, just a short walk from the island's main church, and it's been a fixture of the neighborhood for years. I went there on a Sunday afternoon after church lets out, and the place was full of families in their Sunday clothes, which tells you everything about its role in the community. The pizza here is thicker, more in the style of a Sicilian slice, with a dough that has a noticeable yeasty flavor. They do a meat lovers pizza that includes a local sausage you won't find anywhere else on the island, slightly spicier than standard chorizo. Prices are moderate, around 50,000 pesos for a large. The best time to go is Sunday between 1 and 3 PM, right after the midday meal rush. What most visitors don't realize is that El Italiano also serves a full Colombian lunch menu during the day, and the pizza only appears on the menu after 5 PM on weekdays and all day on weekends.
Local Insider Tip: "If you're there for lunch and want pizza, ask if they have 'pizza de mañana.' Sometimes they'll make you a personal-sized pie from the lunch prep dough if you ask before 2 PM. They won't advertise it, but they'll do it."
This place connects to the older tradition of San Andres dining, where a single restaurant serves the community across the entire day, shifting its identity with the hours.
5. Pizza al Corte (Avenida 20 de Julio, near the bus terminal area)
Pizza al Corte is exactly what the name suggests, pizza by the slice, and it's the closest thing San Andres has to a New York-style slice shop. Located near the bus terminal on Avenida 20 de Julio, it's the kind of place where you walk in, point at what you want, pay, and eat standing up or take it to go. I stopped by last Wednesday around 1 PM after running errands, and there was a line of about five people, all locals. A slice of cheese pizza is around 5,000 to 7,000 pesos, making it one of the cheapest pizza San Andres has. The pepperoni slice is the most popular, and they keep the slices warm under a heat lamp, which isn't ideal, but at that price, nobody complains. Best time to go is midweek lunch, Monday through Wednesday, when the slices are freshest. What tourists don't know is that the owner sources his mozzarella from a supplier in Barranquilla who ships it weekly, and the quality of the cheese is noticeably better than what most island pizzerias use.
Local Insider Tip: "Buy two slices and a soda for under 15,000 pesos total. The owner will sometimes throw in a third slice if you're a repeat customer and he recognizes you. It's not a policy, just his way."
Pizza al Corte represents the everyday, working-class food culture of San Andres, the kind of place that keeps the island fed without any pretense.
6. Restaurante y Pizzería El Caribeño (Barrio La Loma)
La Loma is the highest point on the island, and El Caribeño sits on one of the winding streets that climb up toward the old church at the top. I made the walk up on a Saturday evening, and the view from the small terrace is worth the climb alone, even before you eat anything. The pizza here is good, a standard margherita for about 25,000 pesos personal size, but what really sets this place apart is the setting. You're eating pizza on a hillside in the Raizal heartland of San Andres, surrounded by wooden houses painted in Caribbean colors, with the sound of island music drifting up from below. The best time to visit is Saturday or Sunday late afternoon, around 5 PM, when you can catch the sunset from the terrace. Most tourists never make it up to La Loma for pizza because they don't realize there are restaurants up there, they only come for the church and the view.
Local Insider Tip: "After your pizza, walk five minutes further up the hill to a small house where an older woman sells homemade coconut ice cream for 3,000 pesos. It's the perfect finish, and she's been making it for over twenty years."
El Caribeño connects directly to the Raizal identity of San Andres, a community that has maintained its distinct culture despite decades of mainland Colombian and international influence.
7. Pizzería Mónica (Calle 5, near the school zone)
Mónica's is a small place on Calle 5, close to one of the island's public schools, and it does most of its business in the late afternoon when kids get out of school and parents are looking for an easy dinner option. I stopped by around 4 PM on a Friday, and there were three families with young kids already there. The pizza is straightforward, nothing fancy, but the portions are large and the prices are fair, around 35,000 pesos for a medium. They do a chicken and mushroom pizza that's surprisingly good, with actual sliced mushrooms rather than canned. Best time to visit is Friday afternoon between 3:30 and 5 PM, before the dinner rush. What most people don't know is that Mónica also does takeout orders by phone, and if you call an hour ahead, she'll have your pizza ready for pickup, which is a lifesaver if you're staying in a rental and don't want to deal with the evening crowds.
Local Insider Tip: "Call ahead and ask for the 'pizza familiar,' which is a large pizza cut into small squares, perfect for sharing. It's about 55,000 pesos and feeds four people easily. She'll also throw in a free soda if you mention you're staying on the island for a while."
Mónica's is the kind of neighborhood institution that holds a community together, one pizza at a time.
8. La Casa de la Pizza (Avenida Newball, near the tourist zone)
La Casa de la Pizza sits on Avenida Newball, right in the thick of the tourist zone, and I'll be honest, I was skeptical the first time I walked in. Tourist-zone pizza is usually the worst pizza, overpriced and underwhelming. But this place surprised me. The owner is from Medellín, and he brought his family's recipe with him, and the dough has a slightly different texture, a bit chewier, that I actually prefer. A large pizza runs about 50,000 to 60,000 pesos, which is on the higher side for the island, but the quality justifies it. They do a truffle oil pizza that's unusual for San Andres, and it's genuinely good. Best time to visit is early evening, around 6 PM, before the tourist crowds peak. What most visitors don't realize is that the second floor has a small balcony overlooking the avenue, and it's a great spot to eat while watching the evening street life.
Local Insider Tip: "The truffle oil pizza is only available Thursday through Sunday. The rest of the week, they use a garlic oil that's also excellent. Ask for extra garlic oil on the side either way."
La Casa de la Pizza shows that even in the tourist zone, you can find quality if you know where to look.
When to Go and What to Know
San Andres is warm year-round, with average temperatures between 27 and 30 degrees Celsius, and the pizza culture here follows the island's rhythm. Lunch is the main meal for many locals, so the best pizza between noon and 2 PM is at the neighborhood spots like Pizza al Corte and Mónica's. Dinner picks up around 7 PM and runs until 9 or 10 PM, with the tourist-zone places staying open later. Weekends are busier everywhere, and if you want a table at La Nueva or El Italiano on a Saturday night, arrive before 7:30 PM or expect a wait. Most places accept cash, and some take cards, but it's always safer to have Colombian pesos on hand. The island's ATMs are concentrated along Avenida Colombia and Avenida Newball. Parking is not really a concern for most of these places since the island is small and most people walk or take a moto-taxi, which costs about 3,000 to 5,000 pesos for a short ride.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the one must-try local specialty food or drink that San Andres is famous for?
The island's signature dish is rondón, a coconut milk-based seafood stew made with fish, conch, crab, root vegetables like yuca and ñame, and plantain. It's traditionally served at roadside stalls and small restaurants in the La Loma and El Centro neighborhoods, usually for 15,000 to 25,000 pesos per plate. For drinks, fresh coconut water sold at street stalls for 3,000 to 5,000 pesos is the most iconic island beverage, and many locals also drink "coco loco," a cocktail of coconut water and rum served in a coconut shell, typically priced around 12,000 to 18,000 pesos at beach bars.
How easy is it to find pure vegetarian, vegan, or plant-based dining options in San Andres?
Vegetarian options are available but limited compared to mainland Colombian cities. Most pizzerias and restaurants offer a basic cheese or margherita pizza, and some places like El Rincón del Mango and several spots along Avenida Colombia serve fruit-based dishes, salads, and rice-and-bean plates. Dedicated vegan restaurants are rare, with only two or three on the entire island as of 2024. Travelers with strict plant-based diets should communicate their needs clearly when ordering, as butter and cheese are commonly used even in dishes that appear vegetarian. Expect to pay 15,000 to 30,000 pesos for a vegetarian meal at a casual restaurant.
Is San Andres expensive to visit? Give a realistic daily budget breakdown for mid-tier travelers.
A mid-tier daily budget for San Andres ranges from 150,000 to 300,000 Colombian pesos per person, roughly 35 to 70 USD. A casual lunch at a local spot costs 15,000 to 25,000 pesos, dinner at a sit-down restaurant runs 30,000 to 60,000 pesos, and a personal pizza at a neighborhood pizzeria is 18,000 to 25,000 pesos. Accommodation in a mid-range hotel or guesthouse costs 80,000 to 180,000 pesos per night. Moto-taxi rides across the island are 3,000 to 8,000 pesos per trip. A full day including three meals, transport, and a beach visit can be managed comfortably on 200,000 pesos if you eat at local spots rather than tourist restaurants.
Are there any specific dress codes or cultural etiquettes to keep in mind when visiting local spots in San Andres?
There are no formal dress codes at restaurants or pizzerias on San Andres, and casual beachwear is acceptable at most casual dining spots during the day. However, when visiting La Loma or the church area, locals appreciate modest clothing out of respect for the Raizal community's cultural and religious traditions. It's customary to greet staff and other diners with "buenas tardes" or "buenos días" when entering small establishments, as skipping greetings is considered rude. Tipping is not mandatory but rounding up the bill or leaving 5,000 to 10,000 pesos at sit-down restaurants is appreciated and increasingly expected.
Is the tap water in San Andres safe to drink, or should travelers strictly rely on filtered water options?
The tap water in San Andres is not recommended for drinking by visitors, and most locals also avoid it. The island's water supply comes from a combination of rainwater collection and a desalination plant, and while it meets basic safety standards, the mineral content and occasional inconsistency in treatment can cause stomach issues for travelers not accustomed to it. Bottled water is widely available at shops and restaurants for 2,000 to 5,000 pesos per liter, and many hotels provide filtered water dispensers in common areas. For budget-conscious travelers, buying a large 5-liter jug for around 8,000 pesos and refilling a reusable bottle is the most practical approach.
Enjoyed this guide? Support the work
